Comments: From a certain perspective, the two scholarship categories look a little bit like a figure skating competition. Every year it seems that one or both of the winners are works that appeared on the list of final nominees in a previous year, creating the impression that in order to win, a work has to "wait its turn" before being selected. This also creates the impression that the nominees are of progressively declining quality. If, One Earth, One People, the current winner in the Myth and Fantasy Studies category, was the second or third best nominee in 2009, does that mean that all of the nominees in 2010 are worse than a work that was at best the second-best nominee of 2009? If one of the also-rans from 2010 wins in 2011, does that mean that all of the other 2011 nominees are no better than the second best option from 2010, and compare even more unfavorably to the nominees from 2009? I'm sure this isn't impression that the Mythopoeic Society wants outside observers to take away from their process, but it is the impression that their process gives nonetheless.
Best Adult Fantasy Literature
Lifelode by Jo Walton
Other Nominees:
Avilion Robert Holdstock
Cloud & Ashes: Three Winter's Tales Greer GilmanPalimpsest Catherynne M. Valente
Trickster's Game trilogy (Heartwood, Bloodstone, and Foxfire) by Barbara Campbell
Best Children's Fantasy Literature
Where the Mountain Meets the Moon by Grace Lin
Other Nominees:
Ash by Malinda Lo
Books of Bayern (The Goose Girl, Enna Burning, River Secrets, and Forest Born) by Shannon Hale
Eyes Like Stars by Lisa MantchevThe Hotel Under the Sand by Kage Baker
Scholarship Award in Inklings Studies
Tolkien, Race and Cultural History: From Fairies to Hobbits by Dimitra Fimi
Other Nominees:
Arda Reconstructed: The Creation of the Published Silmarillion by Douglas Charles Kane
Charles Williams: Alchemy and Imagination by Gavin Ashenden
The Evolution of Tolkien's Mythology: A Study of the History of Middle-Earth by Elizabeth A. Whittingham
Planet Narnia: The Seven Heavens in the Imagination of C.S. Lewis by Michael WardMyth and Fantasy Studies
One Earth, One People: The Mythopoeic Fantasy Series of Ursula K. Le Guin, Lloyd Alexander, Madeleine L'Engle and Orson Scott Card by Marek Oziewicz
Other Nominees:
Lilith in a New Light: Essays on the George MacDonald Fantasy Novel by Lucas H. Harriman
Metamorphoses of the Werewolf: A Literary Study from Antiquity Through the Renaissance by Leslie A. Sconduto
Rhetorics of Fantasy by Farah MendlesohnThe Victorian Press and the Fairy Tale by Caroline Sumpter
Go to previous year's nominees: 2009
Go to subsequent year's nominees: 2011
Book Award Reviews Home
No comments:
Post a Comment